16 November 2026

The Alternative Uses Task (AUT) is a widely used performance measure of divergent thinking and creative cognition. The task asks participants to generate unusual and novel uses for common objects, such as a brick. AUT responses are typically scored for fluency (number of ideas), flexibility (number of idea categories or types), and originality (novelty or unusualness of responses).

Why Semantic Distance Matters

Semantic distance, a measure of the cognitive distance between words in meaning, offers an automated alternative to human scoring of AUT responses. By quantifying the conceptual distance between each suggested use and the object itself, semantic distance can provide an objective metric of originality. This approach promises faster scoring and reduces the subjectivity and inconsistency that can arise from human raters.

What SemDis Contributes

A 2020 study in the journal Behavior Research Methods introduced an open platform called SemDis (Semantic Distance) for computing this metric. The researchers found that a latent semantic distance factor, built from an integration of five semantic models, strongly predicted human ratings of creativity and novelty across multiple tasks. Notably, a multiplicative composition model substantially improved the correspondence of semantic distance to human ratings compared to an additive model.

The authors provide an open platform for computing semantic distance, with tutorials and documentation available through the Open Science Framework. This open-source resource will enable researchers to efficiently and reliably measure originality, a key aspect of creative cognition, in a wide range of studies.

What the 13-Item AUT Recommendation Adds

A 2022 paper recommended a set of 13 AUT items for use with semantic distance scoring: belt, brick, broom, bucket, candle, clock, comb, knife, lamp, pencil, pillow, purse, and sock. The researchers advise choosing items for both theoretical and practical reasons, using as many as time allows, and encouraging participants to "be creative."

They also recommend avoiding compound-word prompts, as these can produce more predictable responses, and being cautious about fluency confounds. Participants who generate many ideas are often assumed to be more creative, but quantity can be mistaken for quality. Semantic distance scoring helps disentangle these factors.

Recommended AUT Items for Semantic Distance Scoring
belt
brick
broom
bucket
candle
clock
comb
knife
lamp
pencil
pillow
purse
sock

Key Measurement Issues

While semantic distance holds promise, it has certain limitations. If participants provide random or task-unrelated words, it can distort the scores and compromise data quality. Screening response files for task compliance is therefore crucial. Semantic distance scores may not fully capture the nuances of human creativity. Fusing semantic distance with other metrics, such as human ratings, may yield the most valid and complete assessment of originality.

What This Means for Creative Cognition Research

The combination of the AUT with semantic distance scoring offers a powerful new tool for studying creative cognition. By measuring originality more efficiently and objectively, researchers can explore the cognitive and neural underpinnings of divergent thinking. For instance, a 2026 study found that executive control measures were more closely related to AUT originality than to fluency or flexibility, suggesting that the quality rather than quantity of ideas better reflects divergent creative cognition under executive demands.

As researchers continue to refine and validate these measures, the hope is that they will shed new light on the creative mind and illuminate the pathways to original thinking. By quantifying the cognitive distances we traverse in our imaginings, semantic distance may help map the landscape of human invention.